Weaponising AI for Creative Testing: A Step-by-Step Guide
Creative Testing

Weaponising AI for Creative Testing: A Step-by-Step Guide

Kyle DurstonKyle Durston

October 31, 2023

The digital marketing landscape is evolving rapidly, and at the forefront of this evolution is the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI). As brands and businesses seek innovative ways to optimise their marketing campaigns, AI has emerged as a powerful tool for creative testing. But diving into AI-powered marketing is more than just pressing a button and letting algorithms take over. It requires combining strategy, human intuition, and a deep understanding of how AI can best serve your creative needs.

Step 1: Crafting the Perfect Brief for AI

Understanding the AI's Language:

At its core, AI operates based on the instructions and data it receives. Think of it as a highly sophisticated artist waiting for guidance. In creative testing, this guidance comes as a detailed brief. Your brief isn't just a simple instruction but the foundational blueprint that steers the AI. Unlike human artists who might intuitively grasp the essence of a vague idea, AI requires explicit, comprehensive directions. If you miss out on details, the AI might produce surprising results that are not always pleasant.

Image by vectorjuice on Freepik

The Anatomy of a Good Brief:

A high-quality brief for AI-driven creative testing should encompass the macro and micro aspects of your creative vision. Start with the broader objectives, such as the target audience, campaign goals, and desired emotional impact. Then, dive deep into specifics. If you're looking at visual content, specify colour palettes (down to the HEX codes, if possible), styles, and themes. For written content, provide context, tone, and preferred writing styles. Remember, the more descriptive you can be, the closer the AI's outcome will align with your vision. Your brief is essentially a dialogue with the AI; the richer the conversation, the better the collaboration.

Step 2: Overcoming the Hurdles of AI-Powered Creativity

Recognizing the Challenges:

Like any tool, AI has limitations. Especially in the creative spectrum, it's crucial to understand that while AI is exceptionally data-driven, it might not always capture the intricate nuances of human emotion and intuition. Challenges can arise in various forms: a slightly off-colour palette, copy that feels unnatural, or designs that don't precisely match your envisioned style.

Strategies to Address Them:

1. Segmenting Tasks: Breaking down your creative assignment into smaller, more manageable segments can often yield better results with AI. Instead of asking AI to produce a comprehensive design, perhaps start with individual elements—like a header, a graphic, or a slogan. This step-wise approach can offer you more control and ensure outcomes are closer to your vision.


2. Refining the Output: Use AI as a foundation. Once you receive the initial output, don't hesitate to refine and tweak it. If the AI generates an almost perfect image except for a colour discrepancy, take that image and adjust it manually. This combination of AI efficiency with human touch often produces the best results.

3. Guiding the AI’s Language: If the AI's copy feels off in tone or style, it's possible to guide it. Be explicit about the language style tone, or even provide examples of existing copy that resonates with your brand voice. When given clearer linguistic guidance, AI can adapt and produce content that aligns more closely with your directives.

The key lies in viewing AI as a collaborative partner—one that's exceptionally skilled but still benefits from human guidance.

Image by vectorjuice on Freepik

Step 3: Achieving Harmony between Human Creativity and AI Precision

The Essence of Creativity: 

Creativity is inherently human at its core. It expresses our experiences, emotions, and perceptions of the world. While AI brings unparalleled data analysis and automation capabilities, it doesn't possess the intuitive touch that human creatives bring.

Strategies for a Collaborative Ecosystem:

1. Human Input, AI Output: The beauty of AI is its ability to take human input and magnify its potential. This doesn't diminish the role of human creativity but amplifies it. For instance, a brief infused with human emotions, objectives, and creative direction can be transformed by AI into multiple versions, each catering to different audience segments.

2. Iterative Process: Think of AI as a sounding board. Once an idea is fleshed out, AI can provide variations, insights, and optimisations. But it's up to the human creative to loop back, refine, and finalise the content. This iterative process ensures that the result is both data-driven and emotionally resonant.

3. Training and Refining: Just as human creatives learn and evolve, so does AI. The more feedback and guidance you provide to AI tools, the better they get at aligning with your creative vision. Over time, this creates a harmonious relationship where AI starts to anticipate and better meet your creative needs.

4. Maintaining the Emotional Core: While AI can analyse data and generate content, the human touch infuses emotion into the content. Whether it's the subtle nuances in a design or the emotional undertones in a piece of content, always ensure that the final creative output speaks to the human experience.

Image by vectorjuice on FreepikCopyPrinted items

Step 4: Taking the Leap – Implementing AI in Your Creative Workflow

Starting with a Clear Objective:

The integration of AI into any process begins with clarity. Before diving in, defining what you aim to achieve is essential. Do you want to speed up the ideation process, optimise audience response, or experiment with varied creative strategies?

Practical Steps to Seamless Integration:

1. Choosing the Right Tool:

   - Research: Conduct extensive research to identify AI tools specifically designed for creative testing and optimisation.

   - Demo & Trial: Most tools offer demo versions or trial periods before committing. This is crucial to understand the tool's capabilities and see if it aligns with your needs.

2. Training & Onboarding:

   - In-house Workshops: Organize training sessions to familiarise your creative team with the selected AI tool.

   - Feedback Loop: Encourage team members to provide regular feedback, especially in the initial stages. This can help identify challenges and streamline the integration process.

3. Integration with Existing Workflows:

   - Compatibility Check: Ensure the AI tool is compatible with your existing design and content platforms.

   - Seamless Transition: Consider a phased approach to avoid disruption. Begin with a few projects or campaigns before fully integrating AI into all creative processes.

4. Regular Review and Iteration:

   - Performance Analysis: Periodically assess the effectiveness of the AI tool in achieving your creative objectives.

   - Updates & Upgrades: AI tools, like all software, undergo regular updates. Stay updated to benefit from new features and improvements.

5. Maintain Human Oversight:

   - Quality Check: Even with AI's capabilities, always have a human review for the final touch. This ensures the content remains authentic, emotionally resonant, and aligned with brand values.

   - Feedback to AI: Use these reviews as an opportunity to feed back into the AI, refining its outputs for future projects.

Envisioning the Future of AI-Driven Creative Testing

The Rapid Evolution:

Integrating AI into creative testing is not a fleeting trend; it's a transformative shift redefining the industry's landscape. As AI technologies mature and become more sophisticated, their potential applications in creative testing expand, offering unprecedented efficiency, innovation, and data-driven decision-making advantages.

The Opportunities Ahead:

1. Speed and Efficiency: One of the most immediate benefits is the speed at which AI can operate. What took days of brainstorming, designing, and iterating can now be condensed into a few hours. This rapid turnaround time allows for more iterations, testing, and refining, ensuring the final creative output is optimised for its audience.

2. Data-Driven Brainstorms: With AI's capability to analyse vast amounts of data, creative teams can be presented with insights and ideas they might not have considered. AI can highlight emerging trends and audience preferences or even predict the potential success of a particular creative direction.

3. Personalization at Scale: AI can be pivotal as brands move towards hyper-personalized marketing strategies. It can aid in creating personalised content for diverse audience segments without the traditional time and resource constraints.

4. Collaboration between Humans and AI: The future isn't about AI replacing human creativity but augmenting it. Creative professionals can use AI to handle repetitive tasks, gather insights, and even challenge their creative boundaries, freeing them to focus on strategic and innovative aspects.

Embracing the evolving role of AI in creative testing is not just about staying updated with technology but about harnessing a powerful tool that can elevate creative endeavours to new heights. By understanding its potential and staying abreast of emerging trends, brands and creatives can position themselves at the forefront of this exciting evolution.

Final Thoughts

As we navigate the fusion of artificial intelligence with the world of creative testing, it becomes evident that the confluence of technology and human creativity is not a battleground but a fertile ground for innovation. AI is not here to replace the human touch; instead, it's a catalyst that ignites a renaissance in the realm of creative processes.

While AI provides the data-driven backbone and rapid efficiency, human intuition infuses the soul into creative endeavours.

Brands and businesses stand at the threshold of this new dawn. By embracing AI with an open mind and a clear strategy, they can redefine the boundaries of what's possible in creative testing and marketing. The future beckons with promise, and it's a future where technology and human imagination together craft stories that resonate deeper and wider than ever before.

Ladder powers strategy and performance solutions for fast-growing brands

Talk to a strategist →

Growth is a high velocity game.

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest movements in the field.

More from

796+ open sourced growth tactics used by the best marketers in the world.
Explore our playbooks →